THORSTEN SELLIN

 

His ideas stem from the traditional sociological theory of Conflict Theory and Karl Marx.

 

Culture Conflict Theory

A theory that sought to move away from individual pathologizing as a reason for crime

Criminal acts must be analyzed as conflicts between norms. For every person there is a right (normal) and wrong (abnormal)  way of acting in specific situations - behaviour codes or conduct norms

Societies contain different different groups whose norms of conduct are to some extent divergent

Conduct norms are defined by the groups to which the individual belongs.  Every group one belongs to, regardless of political boundaries, regardless of embodiment in law, has conduct norms

Divergent cultures who come into direct contact within same society or between societies will result in conflict

Culture Conflict is the inevitable result of conflict between conduct norms

Conflict is increased whenever one culture is able to have its beliefs and practices protected by inclusion in the criminal code of the society, that is where one culture's conduct norms are dominant

Dominant groups are able to impose their vision of cultural reality upon weaker groups, which results in deeming the behaviours of the less powerful groups as deviant/criminal

Conflicting cultural norms simply give more occasion for crime and deviance to occur

Crime is just one form of conduct norm violations

Power is the principal determinant of the outcome of this conflict

Deviance is conceptualized not as abnormal behavior but as a normal, political process brought about by inter-group struggle for dominance

 

Thorsten Sellin (1938) emphasized the cultural diversity of modern industrial society. For Sellin, law embodied the normative structure of the dominant cultural/ethnic group. The criminal law contains the "crime norms," inappropriate behavior and its punishment, reflecting the values and interests of the groups successful in achieving control of the legislative process. The "conduct norms" of other, less powerful groups reflecting their specific social situations and experiences often come into conflict (Culture Conflict) with the crime norms. This leads to the production of deviant or criminal definitions surrounding the everyday behavior of the individual members of these less powerful groups. Sellin indicated that as society diversified and became more heterogeneous, the probability of growing and more frequent conflict, therefore deviance, would increase.  


Conflict will be one of two types:

i. Primary conflict - occurs when the norms of two cultures clash
ii. Secondary conflict - occurs within the evolution of a single culture

 

Subordinate culture has two options:  alter culture or risk continued conflict

 

Example:  Children of immigrants, born in "new" country, are often caught between two cultures.

 

http://www.soc.sbs.ohio-state.edu/classes/soc410/reiter/ch09/ch09.PPT

http://tkdtutor.com/06Theory/CriminalMind.htm

http://12.37.252.11/faculty/boutwell/criminology%20CHAPTER%205.htm

http://faculty.ncwc.edu/toconnor/301/301lect01.htm

http://www.prenhall.com/divisions/ECT/app/crim2day/html/ch9.html 

http://www.umsl.edu/~rkeel/200/culflic.html 

 

 

Classical Criminology Theory course documents

Classical Criminology Theorists

Return to MAIN PAGE

 

 

 

Revised: November 18, 2002 .